Whether you’re new to the hobby or getting back into collecting, grading can feel like a maze. PSA, BGS, and SGC all offer different prices, turnaround times, and standards. It’s hard to know when submitting a card is actually worth it. Here’s a simple breakdown to help you make smarter grading choices and avoid wasting money.
🔍 Why Grade at All?
Grading adds three things to a collector’s value:
1️⃣ Authentication guarantees the card is real. Especially important for autographs, vintage, and high-end rookies.
2️⃣ Condition Protection. A slab keeps your card safe from handling, scratches, and fading.
3️⃣ Market Value Boost. A card in a PSA 9 or 10 almost always sells for more than raw. Though, it must be a sought-after card.
🥇 The Big 3 Grading Companies
⭐ PSA (Professional Sports Authenticator).The most trusted in the hobby. Highest resale value in most sports. Clean label and consistent grading. Usually the best choice for modern rookies and parallels.
⭐ BGS (Beckett Grading Services) Known for sub-grades (centering, corners, edges, surface). Strong for thicker cards like patch autos. BGS 9.5’s used to dominate, but PSA has taken the lead again.
⭐ SGC Fastest turnaround. Black tuxedo slabs look great, especially with vintage. Often cheaper and more consistent than the other two.
🧠 When You Should Grade a Card
If the card would sell for significantly more graded. Examples:Star rookies (QB’s, MVP-level players, top prospects). Short prints, case hits, autos. Low-pop inserts and key vintage cards. Check for major flaws. Examine centering, corners, edges, and surface. Look for print lines, dimples, and scratches. If any of these look rough, it’s usually not worth grading.
🛑 When You Should Not Grade
Base cards from overprinted years. Cards worth less than $15 raw, cards with visible damage, or anything modern with bad centering. Grading doesn’t magically create value; it amplifies the value that’s already there.
💵 Understanding Grading Costs in 2025
Prices change often, but here’s the general range. PSA: $20–$30+ for bulk submissions.
BGS: $22–$40 depending on turnaround.
SGC: $15–$20 bulk, often cheaper.
Remember: If your $10 card becomes a $20 card, grading it is not worth the submission fee.
📦 Tips Before Sending Your Cards
Use microfiber cloths to avoid scratching foil. Card savers (not top loaders) are required by most companies. Double-check your card under bright light. Compare comps of PSA/BGS/SGC sales before choosing a company. A little prep can easily turn an 8 into a 9 or a 9 into a 10.
🏁 Final Thoughts
Grading is one of the smartest tools in the hobby when it’s used the right way. By choosing the right cards, the right company, and the right timing, you can maximize value while minimizing cost. If you ever want help deciding whether a specific card is worth grading, just ask. I’m always here to take a look.
Leave a Reply